Index Trackpad Click counts as thumbstick click

[ShyAssassin]

When using Valve Index Controllers clicking down at the top of the trackpad will start transcription when the start action is set as the thumbtack click in settings.
After snooping around the source code i believe this is because unfortunately like thumbstick actions trackpad actions also fire the same event, unlike with thumbsticks the currently implemented deadzone check will not reliably filter out inputs for trackpads.
Before opening this issue i did try a few things to attempt to fix it so i could open a PR but nothing i could think of worked, it may be worth removing openvr in favor of openxr(pyopenxr) as it has separate events for these actions.

[yum-food]

Agreed w/ openxr. openvr is deprecated and the input event filtering is super hacky. Switching libraries is def the move.

FWIW, I personally use the a/b button inputs. This might be a painful but acceptable short-term workaround.

Thanks for the report! I'll try to get to this asap.

[ShyAssassin]

i did try switching over to using a/b for a while but for some reason griping and pulling my hand back activated it at times, although i think that might be an issue with my SteamVR config

[yum-food]

Spent ~3 hours on this so far. Hitting pause for now.

e689105

Notes to self:

• Useful example code: https://registry.khronos.org/OpenXR/specs/1.0/html/xrspec.html#input
• pyopenxr_examples also has some useful stuff
• stopped at the graphics thing; having issues getting session creation to accept my graphics instance. I am running a game while testing. This path needs to work.

[ShyAssassin]

In theory an instance created with the XR_MND_headless extension enabled shouldnt need to have a graphics binding.

[yum-food]

I have a functional prototype done. Working out the bugs and play-testing today. Unless something surprising comes up, it will be in the next release.

[yum-food]

Well, something surprising came up. It seems that two things hold:

• steamvr is in fact using openvr
• openvr does not implement openxr's XR_EXTX_overlay

https://steamcommunity.com/app/250820/discussions/8/3783625016029084617/

So, I think openXR is out of the question.

[yum-food]

The corollary here is that you can't run an openxr app alongside any other app. The openxr app will kill anything running before it, and anything launched after it will kill the openxr app.

After going over the docs for a couple hours and implementing this a couple different ways, there is simply no way to do it.

So I'll focus on openvr and see if there's a better way to sample joystick clicks.

[ShyAssassin]

hmmmm interesting i wonder how other overlay apps like OpenVR Advanced Settings or XSOverlay are able to run alongside other applications.
Im going to do some research and see if i can make something, if i am able to i will share the code here.